Deceleration of the Greenland ice sheet caused by 11,000-year-old events

February 5, 2016 - 06:25

Events that happened 11,000 years ago are still affecting the behaviour of the Greenland ice sheet today, causing it to decelerate.

The Greenland ice sheet moves slower than it once did due to the formation of ‘hard’ ice 11,000 years ago. But can this hard ice protect it from rapid melt associated with climate change? (Photo: Flickr NASA Goddard Space Flight Center)

Today large parts of the Greenland ice sheet move slower than they have in the past, due to a process that began around 11,000 years ago.

At this time, the type of snow accumulating over Greenland suddenly changed, and it is this change that causes the ice sheet to slow down.

“The ice sheet as a whole is still losing a tremendous amount of mass. But what we see here is the fingerprint of how the ice sheet is still responding to processes that were kick-started millennia ago, at the start of the last deglaciation,” says co-author William Colgan, a guest researcher at the Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland (GEUS) and assistant professor in the Department of Earth and Space Science and Engineering at York University in Toronto, Canada.

The new research is published in the journal Science.

Clean ice moves more slowly

11,000 years ago, the Earth was undergoing huge climate changes. The massive ice sheets that once covered large parts of the globe had all but melted and sea levels were rising.

But as the world became warmer and wetter, it also became less dusty, and this change is reflected in the type of ice contained within the Greenland ice sheet.

“Ice deposited during the last glacial period was dustier and contained more air bubbles. This made it softer and more deformable than present day ice, which is cleaner and harder,” says Colgan.

This cleaner, harder ice started to form 11,000 years ago, and it is this ice that has since caused large parts of the ice sheet to slow down.

Greenland is growing and slowing down

As snow falls on the ice sheet, it accumulates in layers, which over time are compressed into ice. So the hard ice that started to form 11,000 years ago is now buried deep with the ice sheet.

But this ice doesn’t just move downwards, it also flows outwards towards the edges of the ice sheet.

In much the same way as a stiff bread dough holds its shape better than a soft dough, the young hard ice flows out to the sides of the ice sheet much more slowly than the older softer ice, causing the ice sheet to slow down.

Here you can see the ice layers of the Greenland ice sheet, collected by radar-stratigraphy on a single flight in 2011. Green lines show ice layers formed after 11,700 years ago. It is these layers of hard ice that have caused large parts of the ice sheet to decelerate (Photo: NASA's Scientific Visualization Studio)

“So when we talk about the deceleration of the ice sheet, what we’re talking about is this harder layer of modern ice that is making its way down through the ice sheet and slowly replacing the softer, older ice at the bottom,” says Christine Hvidberg, a glaciologist with the Neils Bohr Institute, Copenhagen, Denmark.

Hvidberg was not involved in the new research, but describes it as “an important result” that provides “a unique opportunity to see how the ice sheet dynamics have changed over time.”

How vulnerable is the ice sheet to melting?

So can this hard ice slow down the movement of the Greenland ice sheet enough to protect it from the rapid melting observed in recent years due to global warming?

According to Colgan the answer is no, but Hvidberg is more optimistic.

“Melt due to contemporary climate change is really concentrated around the edges of the ice sheet. Here the ice sheet is thinning and glaciers are flowing faster into the sea and we’re losing hundreds of gigatons of ice each year,” says Colgan.

“But the processes that we documented are in the interior of the ice sheet. It’s much more subtle and it in no way offsets that peripheral ice loss,” he says.

But Hvidberg thinks that the ice sheet as a whole is not as vulnerable to climate change as many computer models suggest.

“This [hardening] effect may help the ice sheet to be more resilient towards climate change,” says Hvidberg. “But of course it’s complicated.”

“At the same time [as the ice is becoming harder] temperatures are also increasing. So the ice is now warming up and this starts to make the ice softer again. So exactly how the ice sheet will evolve is complicated by many different processes,” she says.

But the real message, says Colgan, is that the ice sheet is more dynamic that we previously thought.

“This means that we really have to understand these subtle processes that have been happening over the last 11,000 years to fully understand what has happened in the last ten years to be able to accurately predict what will happen in the near future,” he says.

Mapping the inside of the Greenland ice sheet

Colgan and his colleagues used a technique known as radar stratigraphy to analyse the layers of ice right across the Greenland ice sheet.

“Just like radar can be used to image your body and highlight tissues of different density, radar from a plane or a Ski-Doo [snow mobile] transmitted into the ice sheet can bounce back and highlight different layers within the ice sheet,” says Colgan.

Planes with radar equipment have been making these trips across Greenland for almost 20 years, and in 2015 all of these data were combined to produce a 3D map of the inside of the Greenland ice sheet.

In the new study, Colgan and colleagues use these data, to pick out a few ice layers of interest. One of which was boundary layer at 11,700 years ago, marking the transition between soft glacial ice and the harder interglacial ice that has formed ever since, in a period known as the Holocene.

From here, they could work out how much ice had formed and how fast it has been moving over the last 11,000 years.

“This is the first time that this radar data has been analysed to reconstruct the flow and accumulation of ice across the whole ice sheet,” says Colgan.

Video: NASA's Scientific Visualization Studio. See how glaciologists study the interior of the Greenland ice sheet with radar stratigraphy. The new study uses these data to calculate how much ice has accumulated and how fast it flows.

Today's selected stories

What will our climate look like in 2050?

Knowing that we have the power to influence global climate is enormously important when trying to imagine what our climate might look like in 2050. To a large degree, it will depend on actions our leaders take now and in the immediate future.